Image review tool for clients: pin comments, versions and approval for stills
An image review tool lets the client click on the exact spot of a render or design and write what is wrong, on a numbered version, then approve it. Here is what to look for and how to run a round.
The short answer
An image review tool shows the client your image in a browser and lets them click a point on it to leave a comment. The comment is pinned there. You see a numbered marker on the spot, a list of the notes, and which version each one belongs to. When the image is right, the client approves that version.
Client review software is the same idea for any file type. For stills it is simple, and you do not need an enterprise tool to get it.
Why "the left side looks off" is a problem
A client receives a 4K render of a living room. They write: "the left side looks off, and can the lamp be warmer?"
Which left side? The sofa, the window, the wall? Which lamp? There are three. You reply with questions, they answer a day later, and the round takes three days where it should take one.
The same thing happens with design comps. "Make the header bigger" can mean the logo, the headline or the whole block.
A pin removes the guesswork. The client clicks the lamp. The note is on the lamp.
What an image review tool needs
Pin comments on the image
The client clicks a point and types. A numbered marker appears. Click the note in the list and the image jumps to the pin. Click the pin and the note opens. That is the minimum.
Check that the pins stay in place when the image is zoomed. Archviz stills are often 4000 pixels wide, and a client reviewing a window reflection needs to zoom to 200% without the pin drifting.
Versions of the same item
Each new export is a new version of the same image: v001, v002, v003. Comments stay with the version they were made on. The client sees the latest by default and can open earlier ones.
A compare view is worth having. Swiping between v002 and v003 shows the client that their note was done, without you describing it.
Review without an account
Clients will not sign up to comment on one render. The link has to work in a browser, on a laptop and on a phone. Test it yourself in a private window.
Notes you can close
Each pin has a state, open or resolved. You work down the list, resolve each one, and send the next version. The client sees what was done and what was not.
Approval on a version
The client approves a specific version, in the same place. The record shows which version, who, and when. That record matters when a client later asks why the final looks different from the draft.
File handling
Check the file size limits and the formats. Renders arrive as PNG or JPG, sometimes TIFF. Design work arrives as PDF or PNG exports. If the tool cannot display your file, the client sees a download link and you are back to email.
What you can skip for stills
Approval chains with legal, brand and regional sign-off. Automated reminders to 20 reviewers. Version diff overlays on pixel level. These exist in tools such as Filestage and Ziflow and are priced for marketing departments. A studio with one client contact per job rarely needs them. For the tool-by-tool comparison with prices, see online proofing software for creative studios.
Archviz and product renders
Stills for architecture and products have their own review pattern. The client is often an architect, a developer or a brand manager, and the notes fall into groups.
- Geometry: "the window is too narrow." This needs the model changed and a re-render.
- Materials: "the floor should be darker oak." This needs a texture change and a re-render.
- Lighting and mood: "warmer, more dusk." This needs a lighting pass.
- Post: "remove the plant, boost the blue in the sky." This is a retouch in Photoshop and takes minutes.
Sort the pins into these four groups before you start. Group 4 can be done in 10 minutes. Group 1 can take a night of rendering. Tell the client up front which notes cost time. "Notes 2, 5 and 7 need a re-render, about 3 hours at 4K. The rest I can do today."
If a note changes geometry after sign-off on the model, it is a change, not a revision. Your contract decides how it is billed. See archviz client feedback rounds and revision clause for 3D contracts.
Design comps and brand work
For a poster, a landing page comp or a logo set, the client is usually a marketing lead with opinions from three colleagues. Two habits help.
- Show one option or at most three. Ten options produce ten sets of notes.
- Label each variant on the image itself: "Option A", "Option B". The client can then pin "A, the headline" and you know what they mean.
When a note is a taste call, not an error, reply on the pin with what you will try, and keep going.
How to run an image review round
- State the rounds in the quote: two included, a third billed.
- Name the person who approves. Others can comment.
- Export at review size. For a 4K render, a 2400 pixel wide JPG at quality 85 loads fast and shows the detail. Keep the full-size file for the final.
- Upload as a new version of the same item. Name it with the version, for example `Living_Room_v003.jpg`.
- Send the link with a deadline: "Send all notes by Wednesday noon. That closes round two."
- Read the pins once. Ask about the unclear ones before you start work.
- Fix, resolve each pin, export the next version.
- Tell the client what changed and what needs their call.
- On approval, store the version and date. Invoice the milestone.
Mistakes that cost a round
- Sending a JPG as an email attachment and also a link. Two files, two sets of notes.
- Replacing the file on the link. The old comments now point at pixels that moved.
- Letting 4 reviewers comment with no one owning the decision. Name the one who decides.
- Accepting a note by chat. If it is not on the pin, it will be forgotten.
See also how to reduce revision rounds.
Doing this in OIO
Upload the image to a ticket on the project. The client opens the link, clicks to pin a comment on the spot, and approves the version when it is right. No account is needed. New exports stack as versions on the same ticket, and the images can be compared by swiping between versions. You resolve each pin as you fix it.
The tickets, the quote and the invoice sit on the same project page. OIO does not do multi-stage approval chains, so a marketing team with legal sign-off is better served by a dedicated proofing tool.
Plans are Free for 1 project, Solo at $19 a month and Studio at $99 a month, with a 7-day trial.
Questions
What is an image review tool?
It is software where a client views an image in a browser, clicks a point on it to leave a comment, and approves a version. The comments are pinned to the spot.
Do clients need an account to review images?
Not in the better tools. They open a link and comment. Test the link in a private window on a phone before you send it.
What is client review software?
It is a tool that collects a client's comments and approval on your work in one place, tied to a version of the file. It replaces notes scattered across email and chat.
How should I name image versions for review?
Use the item name and a version number, for example Living_Room_v003.jpg. Never overwrite a file the client has already commented on.
Can I compare two versions of an image in a review tool?
Some tools can. OIO stacks versions on one ticket and lets you swipe between them for images. Filestage and Ziflow have more advanced overlay compare.